|
For Immediate Release
September 15, 2000
Contact: John M. Miller, 718-5967668, 917-690-4391(mobile)
U.S. REINSTATES SUSPENSION OF MILITARY ASSISTANCE TO INDONESIA
ETAN Applauds Response to Militia Killings and Unresolved Refugee
Crisis; Calls for International Tribunal and Donor Meeting Delay
The East Timor Action Network (ETAN) today praised the Clinton
Administration's decision to reinstate the U.S. suspension of military
assistance to Indonesia and urged the administration to work to postpone
the World Bank-sponsored Consultative Group on Indonesia (CGI) donor
meeting until key conditions are met. On the eve of Secretary of Defense
William Cohen's visit to Indonesia, ETAN also reiterated its call for an
international tribunal to try those who committed crimes against humanity
in East Timor.
Responding to contacts from ETAN members around the country urging Secretary
Cohen to clarify the Pentagon’s position before his visit, Pentagon officials explained that military cooperation was
currently suspended. ETAN has
consistently advocated that the U.S. end any support for the Indonesian
military by suspending visits and military exercises, and halting any
plans to supply spare parts and other military equipment to the Indonesian
military.
"The steps taken this summer to resume military ties did nothing
to improve the human rights situation in Indonesia or security for East
Timor. The Indonesian military took them as a sign of impunity for their
worst abuses, not as encouragement to reform. The recent murders of three
UNHCR international staff and at least 11 others in West Timor by
pro-Jakarta militia members is only the most prominent example of how much
needs to be done to protect basic rights in Indonesia,” said John M.
Miller, spokesperson for ETAN.
"Our military-to-military relationship with Indonesia at the
moment is suspended," Harold Heilsnis, Director for Public
Communication for the Pentagon, wrote members of ETAN. "In the
future, if necessary reforms and actions are taken, we would like to
re-engage with the military. But that will take place only after certain
actions take place in Indonesia, and after consultations with the
Congress," he added. Unnoticed by most U.S. media a senior Pentagon
official announced at a September 11 press briefing
the suspension of the
U.S. military relationship with Indonesia.
"We expect the U.S. will not resume ties before Indonesia meets
certain critical conditions, including the safe return of East Timorese
refugees, disarming and disbanding of militia groups, arrest and
extradition of their leaders, and Indonesian cooperation with the creation
of an international human rights tribunal for crimes committed in East
Timor. Most critically, there must be civilian control of the Indonesian
military. Secretary Cohen must make these things clear in all his Jakarta
meetings," added Miller.
"Any U.S. assistance to the Indonesian military contributes to the
unraveling of Indonesia's fragile democratization, betrays our commitment
to genuine self-determination in East Timor, and violates the intent of
Congress in withholding aid to human rights abusers," added Lynn
Fredriksson, Washington Representative for ETAN.
ETAN, joining calls by East Timorese leaders,
is urging the U.S. government, other donor countries and the World Bank to
postpone the meeting of the Consultative Group on Indonesia (CGI),
scheduled for mid-October, until Indonesia stops militia violence and
terror, ends cross-border incursions and resumes the voluntary
repatriation of refugees. Some 100,000 East Timorese refugees remain
trapped in camps in West Timor since last year's vote. Since the UNHCR and
other aid agencies have evacuated, few international observers remain in
West Timor to serve as even meager deterrence to further militia violence.
In a letter sent to Indonesian President Wahid after the attack on
UNHCR workers, World Bank President James Wolfensohn warned: "I look
forward to being able to report to donors at next month's Consultative
Group meeting that the violence has ended, that the United Nations has
been able to resume its humanitarian activities and that those who want to
return home to East Timor are now being allowed to do so in safety."
The UN Security Council
in condemning ongoing militia activity on
September 9 called for Indonesia to "take immediate additional steps
to disarm and disband the militia immediately, restore law and order in
the affected areas in West Timor, ensure safety and security in the
refugee camps and for humanitarian workers, and prevent cross-border
incursions into East Timor." Indonesia has so far blocked Security
Council’s efforts to send a mission to Indonesia. U.S. representative to
the UN, Richard C. Holbrooke, has said, "directly or indirectly, it
is elements within the Indonesian military who are responsible for [the
murder of the UNHCR workers], who could have been removed a long time
ago."
In a September 14
editorial, the Washington Post commented:
"Earlier this year the U.S. military had made some exceptions to its
suspension of contact with the Indonesians, and the Pentagon is eager to
restore full military-to-military relations. Now that, too, is on
hold."
"An international tribunal to prosecute those responsible for
violence in East Timor is necessary to realize justice for the East
Timorese. It would have the added benefit of helping to ensure security
for the refugees and those working to assist them. Indonesia should arrest
known militia leaders, immediately place them under protective custody,
and turn them over to UN authorities," said Fredriksson.
In early September 1999, the U.S. suspended military ties and economic
assistance to Indonesia as the Indonesian military and its militias were
destroying East Timor following the August 30 independence vote. Soon
after, the Indonesian military began to withdraw from East Timor and an
international peacekeeping force entered. In November, the U.S. Congress
restricted most military assistance to Indonesia, with renewal contingent
upon East Timorese refugees being safely returned, effective prosecution
of military and militia members responsible for human rights atrocities in
East Timor and Indonesia, and other conditions regarding East Timor's
security.
Last spring, the U.S. military began a planned phased re-engagement
with its Indonesian counterparts. Indonesian officers took part as
observers in a U.S.-sponsored Cobra Gold military exercise in Thailand in
May. In July, a joint U.S.-Indonesian exercise called CARAT/2000, in which
the Indonesian navy, marines, and coast guard trained with their U.S.
military counterparts, took place in East Java.
The East Timor Action Network/ U.S. (ETAN) was founded in November 1991
to support East Timorese self-determination. ETAN supports human rights in
Indonesia and works for a peaceful transition to independence in East
Timor. It has 28 local chapters throughout the U.S.
For additional background see www.etan.org.
-30-
September 13, 2000
Dear _______:
We have read your message regarding the U.S. military relationship with
Indonesia and appreciate having your views. As you know, Secretary Cohen
will visit that nation during his trip to Asia. He has been directed by
President Clinton to raise our concerns about the lack of security in both
West and East Timor. Secretary Cohen will take a strong message to the
leaders of Indonesia.
Indonesia's failure to protect an American citizen and other
international aid workers, and the more general failure of the Indonesian
army to provide security for the international relief operations,
threatens to destroy the international goodwill towards Indonesia at a
time when it needs it most. The Secretary will meet with the top
leadership in Indonesia and the top military leaders. Our
military-to-military relationship with Indonesia at the moment is
suspended. In the future, if necessary reforms and actions are taken, we
would like to re-engage with the military. But that will take place only
after certain actions take place in Indonesia, and after consultations
with the Congress.
This and other points were discussed during a September 8 news briefing
about the Secretary's trip to Asia. Given your concerns, much of the
transcript may be of interest to you and you will find that transcript on
line at: http://www.defenselink.mil/news/Sep2000/x09082000_x908asia.html.
Sincerely yours,
Harold Heilsnis
Director for Public Communication
Note: For those without a fax application on their computer - CallCenter
V3.5.8, is a Native 32-bit Voice Telephony software application integrated with fax and
data communications... and it's free of charge! Download from http://www.v3inc.com/ |