Subject: The Australian: East Timor 'At Risk of Anarchy' Says UN Report
Reuters Update: East Timor Seen Still on Brink of Anarchy
Tuesday, December 23, 2008
East Timor 'At Risk of Anarchy' Says UN Report
EAST Timor risks a repeat of the anarchy that gripped the country in 2006, as it has a dysfunctional police force, a chaotic justice system, a divided political leadership grappling with "dismal" social problems and an economy facing a "precipitous fall" in oil revenue.
The findings are contained in a confidential UN report, obtained by The Australian, which warns that urgent international intervention is required to strengthen East Timor's police and judicial systems to ensure the nation's stability.
The leaked copy of the security assessment, by the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations and dated December 1, warns that the troubled half-island nation remains vulnerable to rapid political collapse.
Australia was forced to send in peacekeepers after the capital Dili exploded into violence in May 2006 when an armed forces mutiny pitted ethnic easterners against ethnic westerners.
The violence led to dozens of deaths, the ousting of the Alkatiri government and tens of thousands of people being left homeless.
The Australian Defence Force has recently withdrawn several hundred troops from East Timor, but 750 Diggers serving as peacekeepers remain.
The report was prepared as part of the UN's evaluations on the future of its peacekeeping operations in the country.
It recommends UN forces remain in the country despite growing pressure from within East Timor for them to depart.
The report is a frank admission of failure by the world body and donors, including Australia, to build a credible and effective police force and judicial system in East Timor.
While focusing mainly on the country's security sector, it sketches a depressing picture of a senior political leadership riven by internal bickering.
The report says political stability in the country continued to depend on the "personal chemistry" of the four leading state actors: Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao, President Jose Ramos Horta, Fretilin opposition leader Mari Alkatiri and army chief Tuar Matan Ruak.
Mr Gusmao is facing a political balancing act, with Timor's economic outlook weakening because of the collapse of oil prices sparked by the global financial crisis.
Despite this, Mr Gusmao must deliver on the need to improve "dismal" socio-economic conditions in the country while trying to strengthen law and order.
"In order to solidify the precarious social conditions, the country may need a special massive employment generation project(s), for example in areas of infrastructure building and agriculture," the report states.
"With regard to the security institutions, there will be no easy choices, and donors should be prepared to provide new reinvigorated assistance in the security area while the Government continues to be under pressure to redeem on its social promises."
While there had been some successes, attempts to create a credible and unified national police force had failed.
"Tremendous institutional gaps persist, including weak management and command and control, lack of core capacities (eg investigations) and an almost total absence of logistics and systems maintenance capacity."
The report describes as "most troubling" the fact the local police appeared to have no budget and noted rising tensions with UN police stemming from unrealistic demands by the Timorese for a bigger policing role.
The Australian Defence Force Academy's East Timor expert, Clinton Fernandes, said time was running out to fix East Timor's legal system.
"Out in the districts, people are just waiting for the next crisis before they start taking action with their own hands," he said.
"I actually see the place cracking and I think the UN report is spot on."
East Timor's court system also attracted a scathing review. The report called for an independent review of the entire Timorese justice sector.
Courts are choked with a backlog of more than 5000 cases, a problem exacerbated by an "acute shortage of judges, legal defenders and rehabilitated court structures" and, apparently, language.
The Government's insistence on the use of Portuguese as an official language means more court bottlenecks because of a requirement for multiple translation services.
While most East Timorese speak native Tetum or Indonesian, few except for the political elite speak Portuguese, the language of the former colonial power.
A demand by Mr Ramos Horta that all court cases be presided over by East Timorese judges from June next year is likely to further stall the delivery of justice, it says.
Portuguese-speaking international judges currently act in a mentoring role and sit with Timorese on cases.
East Timor Seen Still on Brink of Anarchy
CANBERRA, Dec. 23 (Reuters) - East Timor remains on the brink of anarchy and could easily slide back into the violence that fractured the country in 2006, a U.N. peacekeeping report was quoted as saying Tuesday.
It said a "precipitous fall" in oil revenue also threatened to bring more social unrest in a country where three-in-four households were struggling to find enough food and chronic malnutrition hit one-in-two children under 5 in many areas.
East Timor's economy relies on off-shore oil and gas reserves shared with Australia, and which pump around $40 million (27 million pounds) a year into government coffers.
The security report, completed earlier this month for the U.N.'s Department of Peacekeeping Operations, said international peacekeepers must stay in the country despite mounting local pressure for them to leave, the Australian newspaper reported.
"With regard to the security institutions, there will be no easy choices, and donors should be prepared to provide new reinvigorated assistance in the security area while the government continues to be under pressure to redeem on its social promises," it said.
The leaked security assessment warned that nine years after Indonesia's occupation ended and independence in 2002, Asia's youngest nation remained vulnerable to rapid political collapse.
After a split among the military and police in early 2006, violence flared between Timorese from the country's east and west, killing 37 people and driving 150,000 from their homes.
In February this year, rebel soldiers carried out an unsuccessful attempt to kill President Jose Ramos Horta, who was wounded and flown to Australia for surgery. Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao escaped injury in the attack.
The U.N. report said East Timor's police force and courts were largely dysfunctional and required urgent international intervention to strengthen their ability.
Local police were struggling to cope with no operational budget and "troubling" tensions were rising with U.N. police due to unrealistic Timorese demands for a stronger role, it said.
A U.N. spokeswoman in Dili was not immediately available for comment.
More than 2,500 foreign troops and police remain in East Timor to help local security forces maintain stability, the bulk from Australia, New Zealand and former colonial ruler Portugal.
The report, prepared as part of the U.N.'s evaluations on the future of its peacekeeping operations in the country, said East Timor's senior political leadership was bitterly divided.
Gusmao was facing a difficult political balancing act, with Timor's economic outlook weakening because of the collapse of oil prices sparked by the global financial crisis, while needing to improve social conditions, it said.
(Reporting by Rob Taylor; Editing by Jeremy Laurence)