Subject: JSMP: Presidential Pardons: No Substitute for Justice

Press Release

Presidential Pardons: No Substitute for Justice

25 April 2008.

The previous week saw the country rejoice at the safe return of President Josť Ramos-Horta, now recovered from an attempt on his life.Since the Presidentís re-entry into political life, he has made a number of suprising public statements, most recently this last Wednesday, 23 April.

In an address to Parliament, Dr Ramos-Horta announced his intention to grant Presidential pardons to more than eighty convicted criminals.Former Fretilin government minister Rogerio Lobato would be among those pardoned for good behaviour while serving their sentences, he said.

Lobato, found guilty of manslaughter and of using firearms counter to public order, has served only five months of a seven and a half year prison term.A panel of judges concluded that his role in arming civilian groups during the 2006 crisis contributed to the ensuing violence and instability.

Under the Constitution, the President is empowered to grant pardons or commute sentences after consultation with the Government.Accordingly, it is hoped that this pronouncement will not be given effect without due consultation. Such a duty must not be exercised unilaterally.

Particular care must be taken to ensure Presidential pardons do not simply become a means by which the political agenda may subvert judicial process.The singling out of Rogerio Lobato as worthy of clemency may make it hard to avoid the implication that there is little political will to see him face justice.

In fact, few of those who perpetrated criminal acts during the breakdown of law and order in 2006 have yet been held responsible in the courts.The reports of the CAVR and Commission of Inquiry processes have strongly warned against neglecting the public need for legal redress of past wrongs.

Civil society groups, including JSMP, successfully lobbied the Office of the President to veto a proposed amnesty law that would excuse serious offences.The President has spoken about building a culture of forgiveness in Timor-Leste. This must not lead to the further entrenching of a culture of impunity.

Should you ask any further information, please contact:

Timotio de Deus

Director JSMP

Mob: 3323883 / 7292909

E-mail: <>


This article was sent to you by the Judicial System Monitoring Programme (JSMP). Through the provision of independent legal analysis, court monitoring and community outreach activities JSMP aims to contribute to and evaluate the ongoing process of building a strong and sustainable justice system in Timor Leste. Visit our website at

JSMP does not guarantee the content or endorse the views contained in articles distributed the list other than in respect of those publications prepared by JSMP itself

To subscribe send a blank email to: (Daily News and JSMP Publications) (JSMP Reports) (JSMP Justice Updates) (JSMP Press Releases)

Back to April Menu

World Leaders Contact List
Main Postings Menu