Review: Womens Rights in East Timor
From One Day to Another: Violations of Womens Reproductive and Sexual Rights in
East Timor by Miranda E. Sissons
East Timor Human Rights Centre, Melbourne, Australia. 1997
Review by Sonya Hurston, ETAN Northern CaliforniaHuman rights abuses in East Timor
are well-documented. Abuses affecting only women, however, have been left largely
unresearched and under-reported. Miranda Sissons "From One Day to Another:
Violations of Womens Reproductive and Sexual Rights in East Timor helps fill this
serious gap.
In less than 50 pages, Sissons presents East Timorese womens voices, Indonesian
and international human rights laws, and a clear overview of Indonesian reproductive
health programs and policies. Her report not only unearths important data on
Indonesias human rights record in East Timor; it also provides information about
womens rights and the Family Planning (KB) program in Indonesia. Most importantly,
the report describes what women in East Timor must live through "from one day to
another."
Sissons book documents frequent reports of rape, cruel and degrading treatment,
and sexual servitude to Indonesian soldiers in East Timor. Her primary focus is the role
of the KB program in systematizing human rights abuses.
While this program has received international recognition (Suharto twice received the
UN Population medal) for its "effectiveness," it has repeatedly been described
as violating womens rights to information, contraceptive choice, and overall health.
Sissons report describes how severe and systematic violations of womens
reproductive and sexual rights in East Timor have contributed to a strong belief in East
Timor that the KB program is "used by the Indonesian government as a
politically-motivated instrument to deliberately undermine the survival of the East
Timorese as a national group."
Sissons explains that the same military which has killed hundreds of thousands of East
Timorese since 1975 helps recruit for the KB program. "If we do not go, our fathers
or brothers will be persecuted," one East Timorese woman explains. It is not just the
military, however, that is distrusted.
Women in East Timor tell stories of friends and relatives losing babies in
Indonesian-controlled hospitals or becoming sterile after receiving mysterious injections.
Female high school students describe being injected with "vaccinations" that
often stop menstruation.
"Fear of the KB program," Sissons writes, "has severely undermined the
efficacy of the government health system in East Timor. According to statistics in the UN
World Population Report (1996), the death rate in East Timor is double that in Indonesia
and the worst in Southeast Asia. Infant mortality in East Timor outstrips even that of
Rwanda and Iraq. Yet women are unwilling to turn to the government health system for fear
of covert injection or sterilisation."
"From One Day to Another" provides data that is well substantiated and
staggering. This evidence shows the Indonesian government to be complicit in willful abuse
of East Timorese women. Sissons speaks with the authority of international agreements,
Indonesian law and with human concern. Sissons research is impressive and her
writing powerful.
Anyone who wishes to better understand the status of human rights in East Timor should
read this report. And the credibility and effectiveness of those working in solidarity
with the people of East Timor will only be strengthened by a better understanding of the
daily lives of East Timorese women.
"From One Day to Another" is
available
from the ETAN National Office for $6 (postpaid). Its author, Miranda Sissons, is on the
ETAN Executive Committee and currently lives in New York.